top of page

Create Your First Project

Start adding your projects to your portfolio. Click on "Manage Projects" to get started

The Promise vs. The Reality: How a Law Meant to Save Lives is Being Used to Destroy Them

Gauteng

Gauteng surrounding areas

Project type

Legal Assistance for Victims

The Promise: A Landmark of Hope

In 1998, South Africa took a monumental step forward. The Domestic Violence Act (No. 116 of 1998) was born from a simple, powerful promise: no one should be unsafe in their own home.

Its purpose was clear:

- To protect victims from all forms of abuse—physical, emotional, economic, and sexual.
- To empower them with swift, accessible legal tools, like protection orders.
- To validate their experiences, ensuring the state would stand with them, not against them.

This law was meant to be a shield. A lifeline. It was a declaration that the walls of a home should not be a barrier to justice.

The Reality: A System Betrayed

Tragically, for a growing number of victims, this shield has been twisted into a sword. The very system designed for their protection is now being weaponized against them, with devastating consequences.

This is the unseen war at home, where seeking safety can land you in jail.

The Retaliatory Trap: A Perpetrator's Masterstroke

1) She Seeks Safety: Following the law’s promise, a woman bravely obtains a protection order against her abuser.
2) He Strikes Back: In a calculated move, the abuser retaliates by laying a false assault charge against her.
3) The System Fails: She is arrested. At her first court appearance—alone, terrified, and without immediate legal help—she is remanded into custody.
4) Justice Becomes Injustice: The bureaucratic wheels turn slowly. What begins as a 7-day remand stretches to 14, then 21 days before bail is even argued. An innocent mother spends three weeks in a cell.

The Human Cost of a Broken Promise

The consequences of this systemic failure are catastrophic:

- Her children are left motherless, enduring fresh trauma.
- Her job is lost, destroying her financial independence.
- Her spirit is shattered. The law that promised to protect her has now broken her.

This is not a legal loophole. It is state-sanctioned coercion. The abuser's goal is achieved: he manipulates the system to force her to withdraw her protection order in exchange for dropping his false case. The victim is punished, the abuser walks free, and the justice system becomes an instrument of the abuse it was meant to prevent.

This is not an isolated incident. It is a systemic betrayal of the Domestic Violence Act's founding promise.

We must demand a justice system that lives up to its name. The promise of 1998 must become the reality of today.

Share this story, share your story. Break the silence. The first step to fixing a broken system is to expose it.

bottom of page